28 October, 2025

Where do I belong?

Loribeth's post here, about a dream prompting questions about where she belongs, got me thinking. As she rightly said, many childless and perhaps even childfree people ask that question. 

I without doubt belong in New Zealand. Right now I belong in my city too, although my affections for it have plummeted these last few weeks, as our house has been battered with spring winds. I was caught thinking about where else I could live. I could move to the South Island where I have another sister and nieces and great-nephews, and one or two old friends. I have a fondness for that area. But my life has been very different, and so I don't think I belong there any more. There are other spots around the country that might be nice to live in, but where I might struggle to belong. A wealthy farming area has a charming wine village we love to visit but might be stifling to live in. Big cities can be thrilling but lonely. At one stage I belonged in Bangkok. I lived and worked there, loved being in an exciting environment, and felt very much at home amongst the Thais, even though I stuck out like a sore tall white thumb! But each time I return, I feel like I belong less and less. A friend has recently returned there, and feels that maybe she was trying to recapture a life that has passed. At one time we belonged, but do we still?

Even when I travel, I feel I belong - maybe as a tourist, rather than a local. But I'm not bothered by that. Sure, there might be some environments when I feel "out of place," but as long as I am engaged and exploring and enjoying myself, it's easy to feel comfortable, to feel as if I belong. Or perhaps I lie. Because when I travel too, on my own, I can feel terribly alone. Though I know it is possible to feel that without leaving home too.

But do I need to belong anywhere? I'm "at home" wherever I am if my husband is with me. We've been together for so long, he is my home. But I now know that's not going to be permanent. So I ask these questions anew. I think I prefer to belong to people rather than places. And that's the area I struggle. I need more people in my life. In the meantime, I have my sisters, nieces, and most importantly on a day to day basis, my friends who have also become my family. 

I remember after my ectopics and final resolution into a No Kidding life, I was desperate to travel and learn a language and spend time living somewhere else. I wanted to escape. I forgot, though, that I could not outrun my grief. I couldn't leave myself. My childlessness would follow me everywhere. 

I think maybe that's why we question where we belong. Because without children, we have always felt on the outside, as if we don't belong. Not in the way many parents feel they do - in their religions, schools, communities, and wider societies. We are always marginalised. I feel it less these days, as I mentioned here. But I still feel it. In all those places where parents feel validated, I feel othered. 

Belonging becomes something I've learned to do without. It doesn't mean I like it. But I've never quite thought about it this way before. As I read Loribeth's post, I jotted down my instinctive answer. I belong wherever I am. I belong in myself. Because that's who I need to survive. A healthy, contemplative, open and objective Mali with all her flaws. I take it all with me, and belonging comes with contentment, with acceptance, and with gratitude. I sometimes have to be reminded to find all those, but when prompted, it's possible. And then I can face the future. That's my answer. Wherever I am, I belong with me. Or perhaps, 

I am, therefore I belong.


 

 


3 comments:

  1. Thought provoking post! Loribeth's dream really resonated with me, and now this post does too.

    I've never felt like I belonged anywhere. Maybe it's because we moved a lot when I was a kid. I'm also odd-man-out in my family of origin. My parents have each other. My older sisters always had each other. My niece and nephew have each other. And then there's me. Then add in the whole divorced and childless thing... I don't really have a place in society either.

    Instead of feeling sad about it, I've embraced it. I am free to go wherever I want. I don't "belong" anywhere so I'm also not stuck anywhere. I joke that home is where my recliner is or home is where my sewing machine is. But really, it's both of those things plus my boyfriend and our cats. I don't need a lot. I love what you said: "Belonging becomes something I've learned to do without."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thought provoking indeed! Sending you love as the wind and other circumstances have you unmoored. I feel like the older I get the less tolerance I have for staying in places where I don't feel I belong, but I love the idea of "I belong where I am." It's hard to feel like you have to carve out your belonging in a world that doesn't exactly value childless women. But thinking on it, I belong with my books and cat and Bryce, I belong in my classroom, I belong in this community with you. 💜💜💜

    ReplyDelete
  3. Love how you took my original post and replied and expanded on it! :) I am glad you have places where you feel you belong. And when I think about it I definitely get that feeling of belonging in our childless/ALI community! :)

    ReplyDelete